Toggle Side Panel
Close search
Show
by
  • Profile photo of Jonathan Allen

    Jonathan Allen posted an update 5 weeks ago

    5 weeks ago (edited)

    Method Help

    What are your personal rules for giving constructive reviews to papers you f...

    Method Help

    Reviewing a weak paper requires balancing honesty with professionalism. Harsh but unhelpful reviews help no one, while overly gentle ones waste the process. What tone and content do you aim for when reviewing a clearly weak manuscript?

    Mateo, Maverick and 4 others
    5 Comments
    View more comments
    • Profile photo of Minghua Lv
      Minghua Lv

      Identify the specific fundamental flaws rather than attacking the authors’ competence.

      2
      5 weeks ago
      • Profile photo of Jing Yang
        Jing Yang

        Suggest concrete directions for improvement where possible.

        2
        5 weeks ago
        • View more comments

      Report

      Harassment or bullying behavior
      Contains mature or sensitive content
      Contains misleading or false information
      Contains abusive or derogatory content
      Contains spam, fake content or potential malware

      Block Member?

      Please confirm you want to block this member.

      You will no longer be able to:

      • See blocked member's posts
      • Mention this member in posts
      • Invite this member to groups
      • Message this member
      • Add this member as a connection

      Please note: This action will also remove this member from your connections and send a report to the site admin. Please allow a few minutes for this process to complete.

      Report

      You have already reported this .