-
When is it acceptable to perform additional new analyses during manuscript r...
Paper Discussion
During revision many authors run brand‑new analyses beyond what original submission contained. Some new analyses are reasonable responses to reviewer feedback, others expand manuscript scope substantially. Where should authors draw this boundary during rebuttal work?
Benjamin Hill, Anthony Anderson and 15 others4 Comments-
New analyses directly answering explicit reviewer requests are fully appropriate.
2 -
Large brand‑new exploratory research outside reviewer questions should usually go to future papers.
2 -
Always inform editor in cover‑letter when you add substantial new analysis datasets.
2 -
Avoid expanding manuscript core story far beyond original submission’s intended scope.
2
-