-
Practical checklist for reviewing computational reproducibility of other peo...
Method Help
When you act as reviewer for computational papers, verifying reproducibility is important but time‑consuming. Without running full code locally you still can assess reproducibility readiness. What checklist points do you go through during manuscript review?
Dennis Campbell, David Brown and 22 others4 Comments-
Check whether key hyper‑parameters, environment and dataset versions are fully documented.
2 -
Evaluate if described steps give enough detail for independent third‑party recreation.
2 -
Notice missing description of random seeds, data splits and pre‑processing workflows.
2 -
Assess completeness of links pointing to code repository and raw dataset resources.
2
-