-
Should authors explicitly discuss competing papers that reach contradictory ...
Paper Discussion
Many manuscripts only cite supportive prior work while glossing over papers reporting opposite findings. Ignoring contradictory literature can weaken the persuasiveness of your argument. How thoroughly should you engage with conflicting published results?
Jianping Cao, Jian Jia and 55 others4 Comments-
Directly acknowledge major contradictory publications in your related‑work or discussion section.
2 -
Offer fair‑minded potential explanations for observed outcome divergence.
4 -
Avoid dismissive wording when describing competing contradictory results.
2 -
Point out key differences in experimental setup that could drive different conclusions.
2
-