Kyle Morris
-
What should you do when a reviewer cites an unpublished thesis that you cann...
Question
A reviewer cites an inaccessible PhD thesis as critical context for their comment. You cannot obtain the document. How do you respond fairly?
Tping, Jessica and 9 others2 Comments-
Politely ask the reviewer or editor to share key relevant excerpts.
-
State that you cannot evaluate the source without access.
-