Luna
-
How to build a lightweight internal peer review pipeline before journal subm...
Method Help
Many groups run internal pre‑review rounds before sending manuscripts out. It helps catch flaws early and reduces review cycle waste. What does your lightweight internal peer review workflow look like?
Aaron Roberts, Tping and 9 others4 CommentsView more comments-
Set a fixed short review window to avoid indefinite delays.
2 -
Separate content critiques from copyediting checks.
2 - View more comments
-
-
What is your approach to reviewing a paper that falls outside your direct ex...
Method Help
Reviewers sometimes receive manuscripts outside their core specialisation. Reviewing such papers requires extra care to avoid unfair or shallow assessments. How do you responsibly review work that is only partially inside your expertise?
View more comments-
Focus your assessment on methodology and clarity aspects you can genuinely evaluate.
2 -
Read relevant background literature quickly before forming strong judgements.
2 - View more comments
-
