-
How to respond when reviewers raise overly harsh comments
Receiving tough reviewer feedback is normal in academic publishing. Stay objective, respond point‑by‑point and avoid emotional replies, even if you disagree with certain viewpoints.
Martin, Alexander Baker and 13 others5 Comments-
I once got very critical reviews and almost gave up resubmission.
2 -
Make sure every rebuttal point has solid supporting evidence.
2 -
Co‑author discussion really helps calm your mind down.
2 -
Some reviewer comments are subjective, you can politely argue back.
2 -
Keep your rebuttal letter polite no matter what happens.
2
-