-
What is your approach to reading and evaluating supplementary materials of s...
Method Help
Supplementary appendices contain many critical experimental details. But reviewers are often short on time and tend to skim or skip supplementary content entirely. What is your personal routine for working through manuscript supplementary material in your review process?
Luna, Madelyn and 7 others4 Comments-
First scan supplementary table of contents to understand what material is stored there.
2 -
Focus review effort on supplements directly linked to core manuscript claims.
2 -
Flag situations where critical validation evidence is entirely pushed into appendices.
2 -
Note gaps in supplementary documentation that hurt work reproducibility.
2
-