-
How to give constructive peer‑review comments
Writing peer reviews is an essential academic skill. Kind, specific and evidence‑based feedback benefits both authors and the whole community, instead of vague negative remarks.
Gregory Adams, George Perez and 37 others7 Comments-
I try to separate major concerns from minor suggestions clearly.
2 -
Some reviewers give overly general comments with no concrete advice.
2 -
Review training courses would be helpful for new researchers.
2 -
Respect authors’ work even if you disagree with arguments.
2 -
Time cost of peer reviewing should not be ignored.
2 -
Journals need to recognize reviewers’ contributions better.
2 -
Many early‑career researchers feel unqualified to review papers.
2
-